Where Does Dialogue End and Submission Begin?

Driven in part by migration and higher birth rates, Islam, once a minority faith in Britain, now has around four million followers and continues to grow. The expansion of Muslim communities has also brought debate about integration and the risks of radicalisation.

Some governments in the Gulf, including Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates, have publicly expressed concern about extremist influences in parts of Europe. In recent years, some families from those countries have reportedly reconsidered sending their children to prestigious British boarding schools and universities, fearing exposure to radicalised interpretations of Islam among diaspora communities.

Against that backdrop, some Church of England parishes have hosted iftars during Ramadan, inviting Muslims to break their fast inside church buildings. To supporters, such events are gestures of hospitality and interfaith goodwill. However, they raise deeper theological concerns. Islam explicitly rejects doctrines that lie at the heart of Christian belief. For that reason, some Christians argue that hosting Islamic observances in Anglican churches risks blurring essential religious boundaries at a moment when the Church itself is already weakened.

Weak Leadership and Adherence to the Zeitgeist

The newly appointed Archbishop of Canterbury, Sarah Mullally, has so far not objected to iftar events being hosted on Church of England premises. On the contrary, she is often seen at interfaith and intercultural events in London. One question about how interfaith the dialogue really is concerns the degree to which Christian hospitality is reciprocated: mosques do not seem to welcome Anglicans for Evensong. 

Other theological questions, such as late-term abortion, do not appear to concern the new archbishop either. She has scheduled a pilgrimage to Canterbury, where Chaucer’s medieval pilgrims went, that coincides with the vote on related legislation in the House of Lords this Wednesday. If the measure passes, Great Britain would have one of the most permissive abortion regimes in the world. It may not be lost on some observers that Canterbury hosts the bones of St Thomas Becket, murdered for standing up to the temporal authorities. In contrast, the Church of England appears reticent to challenge today’s elite. 

Perhaps that is why Catholicism recently overtook Anglicanism in the number of believers going to church every week. In Britain, Catholicism was long persecuted, meaning that it has developed an instinct for resisting social pressure. While it is not without similar problems, that history of resistance has helped it to maintain greater adherence to orthodox belief. For many believers, that certainty has become very attractive as Britain becomes increasingly multi-faith. 

National Identity and a Diminishing Religion

Interestingly, the Church of England is growing on a different continent: Africa. Christianity is spreading in many African countries, with some even sending missionaries to reconvert the nation that first brought them Christianity. But there are many differences from mainline Anglicanism in Great Britain. They are more conservative on theological issues such as abortion, the ordination of women to the priesthood and gender identity/LGBTQ. The latter topics are on the verge of causing a schism within Anglicanism.

Whether the Church of England can recover its sense of purpose remains an open question. It is a state church, and in some ways, it is used to follow the attitudes of the British elite. As those views have diverged from Christian orthodoxy, so too have many Anglicans. Institutions that once shaped the moral and cultural life of a nation rarely disappear overnight, but they can slowly lose their authority when confidence in their message weakens. The permissiveness toward Islam makes the Christians involved look less sure of their faith. Respect doesn't warrant letting another religion use religious buildings to hold its own religious events there.

At a time when Britain’s religious landscape is becoming more diverse and contested, the Church of England faces a difficult choice: should it adapt to a multi-faith society at the risk of losing its identity, or resist prevailing liberal orthodoxies and risk open conflict with the establishment? Whatever course it takes, widening divisions across the Anglican Communion raise the prospect of a new schism that could further erode its authority and role.

You might be interested A Catholic guide to Christian–Muslim dialogue in Germany