Editorial: Doom Postponed

Predicting economic disasters might just be the second-oldest profession. Year after year, experts solemnly assure us that the end is nigh: economic apocalypse is just one misstep away. Yet, somehow, despite their impressively consistent pessimistic outlook, the world keeps turning, leaving the doomers repeatedly scrambling for explanations or merely postponing their apocalyptic forecasts.

Take Argentina, where President Javier Milei has been running an audacious economic experiment that even the International Monetary Fund finds unnerving. Milei's shock therapy—ending state-funded excesses, aggressively devaluing the peso, and edging towards full dollarisation—brought inflation down from a staggering 276% to ‘just’ 43.5% by mid-2025. But at what price? With poverty peaking above 60% and public-sector wages tumbling, Argentinians might feel less than thrilled. Still, Milei's blunt admission that ‘there is no money,’ strikes a chord—perhaps because Argentines are accustomed to apocalyptic prophecies that usually fail to materialise entirely.

Doom Delayed

Across the Atlantic, Italy, long considered Europe's ticking time bomb, is enjoying a surprising streak of stability under Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni. Inflation has been reined in, bond spreads are down, and Italy's GDP per capita has nearly caught up with France’s. Meloni's cautious economic policies, such as scrapping the controversial basic income scheme and being pragmatic in cooperating with Brussels, have proven rather effective. Italy might not be booming, but it’s also far from the collapse that many so confidently predicted over the last decade.

Contrast this with the constant chatter about stagflation due to befall the United States, haunted as the country still is by the disastrous 1970s. The current US Federal Reserve, under Jerome Powell, dances precariously between Trump-era economic disruptions, energy market volatilities, and an uncertain geopolitical climate.

Trump labels Powell ‘Mr. Too Late,’ implicitly blaming him for any potential economic downturn. While inflation creeps upward and growth forecasts dim, American policymakers wrestle with old dilemmas. The ghost of Paul Volcker’s infamous 20% interest rate hike still haunts their decisions, making decisive action nearly impossible under today's crippling debt levels.

Meanwhile, Central Europe's Visegrad group provides an instructive counterexample. Poland, Hungary, and Czechia, stubbornly clinging to their own currencies, have largely navigated crises more adroitly than their euro-bound neighbour Slovakia. Currency sovereignty allowed Poland to flourish despite global shocks, while Hungary’s mismanagement underscores how autonomy can also breed instability. Still, as storm clouds gather over the global economy, the Visegrad non-euro trio now appears prescient rather than obstinate in having decided to keep hold of their currencies

In Asia, China is rewriting the inflation playbook entirely. With consumer prices near zero and China’s growth being modest yet its economy stable, Beijing demonstrates an impressive level of control. Unlike the reactive approach of Western central banks—with their penchant for interest rate hikes amid prayers for inflation to ease—China preemptively manages prices through state intervention. Rather than chasing short-term boosts, China's government focuses on ‘productive reflation,’ carefully orchestrating investments in manufacturing and infrastructure. This technocratic calm might not be particularly exciting, but it certainly insulates China from the whiplash that keeps Western economists up at night.

The Lust For Ruin

These examples illuminate why economic doom-sayers persist: the unpredictability and interconnectedness of global markets offer endless fodder for catastrophic predictions. Doom sells, not because it’s accurate, but because it feels plausible, particularly when stakes seem high and leaders unpredictable. Yet history consistently shows us that the most dramatic predictions rarely unfold as promised.

Perhaps the problem isn't that economists predict too many disasters; it's that they underestimate human resilience and adaptability. Economies stagger, yes, but they also recover, often defying the gloomy models economists so confidently cite.

After all, while economic forecasts, like weather predictions, might help guide us, they never should be taken as gospel. In the meantime, the doom industry thrives—not because it's right, but because we're all secretly fascinated by the apocalypse that never quite arrives.

Statement

Despite frequent warnings of imminent doom, the global economy stubbornly refuses to neatly fit into any apocalyptic scenario. Through harsh reforms, Milei’s Argentina has achieved stability. It has staved off runaway inflation, yet it leaves citizens grappling with stark realities. Italy is quietly stabilising under Meloni's prudent governance, assuaging its long-held pessimism. Haunted by past trauma and beset by political inertia, the US teeters on stagnation and is burdened by enormous debt, highlighting the difficulty of taking decisive action. Central Europe demonstrates how currency autonomy offers resilience yet creates vulnerability, while China's calm management stands in contrast with the West’s. In the end, economic apocalypse remains forever postponed—much to the frustration of professional pessimists everywhere.

Weekly