A Catholic Family's Legal Battle over Daughter's Secret School Transition

https://twitter.com/LawEnforceToday/status/2100298675515990316

The Kutzkos are supported in their legal battle by the Child and Parental Rights Campaign. Their attorney, Vernadette Broyles, told Fox News that the whole episode began with LGBTQ school policies.

"You start with school policies that refuse to inform parents when a child rejects their sex and claims another identity", Broyles said, adding that such policies were part of a system that "starts everything down the rabbit hole".

A School-To-State Pipeline

Broyles identified a "direct school to DCF pipeline" in the case, which led to the Kutzkos losing custody of their then 15-year-old daughter. The state now holds guardianship of Sophie, and, after Sophie herself petitioned for it, a permanent restraining order that bars her parents and older brother from contacting her.

Local reporting indicates that the school denies the Kutzkos' characterization of events, saying its contact with the DCF related instead to allegations of abuse against Sophie's father, Joseph, which require automatic notification of the authorities.

https://twitter.com/FoxNews/status/2099509935277060475

According to the Boston Herald, the case was resolved through a non-guilty disposition reached with prosecutors, resulting in pre-trial probation expected to be lifted after one year provided the father commits no further offenses. Separately, the charges are set to be dropped in December, on condition that he completes an anger-management course and has no contact with his daughter. The family's attorney therefore argues that the abuse claims have been found to be baseless.

The Kutzkos' legal efforts are now focused on preventing the state from administering testosterone to their daughter, a procedure they have so far managed to block.

The Case Draws National Attention

Since their appearance on the Fox News podcast, the Kutzkos' plight has captured the attention of a wide range of concerned onlookers.

TreVeyon Henderson, a running back with the New England Patriots American football team, responded to Fox News's coverage of the case by quoting a passage from the Bible, Proverbs 22:6, on the right of parents to guide their children according to their faith.

"Yet, this God given right that these parents have is being stripped away from them by the state", Henderson wrote on the social media platform X, describing the Kutzkos as parents who want to "honor our Lord" and lead their daughter into the truth, away from that which would destroy her.

"May justice be served", he concluded.

Meanwhile, Kristen Waggoner, chief executive of the Christian legal-advocacy organization Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF), encouraged her followers to remember the case the next time they were told that schools do not secretly transition kids.

"Yes. They. Do. Secret social transitions are real, they're devastating, and in this case they appear to have led directly to a child's forced separation from her family", Waggoner said.

Alongside the organization representing the Kutzkos, ADF has been at the forefront of legally challenging secret social transition policies in America, as well as taking on other cases related to gender ideology.

An Oregon Mother Blocked from Fostering

An Oregon mother represented by ADF has recently settled a three-year lawsuit against state officials, which had challenged her exclusion from adopting a child on the grounds that she refused to accept gender ideology, including its prescriptions for resolving identity-related confusion in children, such as the so-called "gender-affirming" approach.

Oregon child-welfare officials have agreed to a court order allowing Jessica Bates to seek a license to adopt children from foster care without violating her religious beliefs about human sexuality.

Commenting on Bates's legal battle, ADF Senior Counsel Johannes Widmalm-Delphonse noted children suffer when people of faith are excluded by the government from foster care because of an "ideological crusade".

Widmalm-Delphonse added that Oregon officials had turned Bates away simply because of her common-sense belief that parents should help children become comfortable with who they are, rather than pushing them down a path of confusion and medicalization.

For her part, Bates, a widowed mother of five, said she was surprised to feel what she interpreted as God "nudging" her to adopt.

"I never dreamt it would lead to a years-long lawsuit when Oregon excluded me just because of my religious convictions about gender", she explained, adding that she was grateful to ADF for taking up her case.